This post is in response to several things I've read and heard lately about the use of devices to connect to the internet in medical school large group teaching sessions. Essentially these posts or comments have been either strongly in favor of the introduction of these technologies, or strongly against. I haven't found much of a middle ground.
Those against argue from the idea of distraction. The argument is laid out in several recent research studies looking at the effects of multitasking on cognitive performance. The basic idea is summarized pretty well here, in an article from the San Fransisco Chronicle. This is the view held by many basic science course directors who make comments to the effect of, 'if they have their laptops out, they are likely playing solitaire.' I've also seen some people speaking about generational differences in learning styles who state that the Millenial generation has grown up with multiple electronic devices going. This falls back on the data that they feel like they have done this for a long time, and should be good at it, but they are not really. As they don't have any insight into this potential hazard, we as course directors should act to squash this tendency by telling everyone to turn off their electronic devices. Hence, the common wisdom among these presentations is that it is important to have the learners switch off their devices on entering the classroom for their own good.
On the other hand, there are many potential up sides to having a wired classroom. First, audience response systems using web-based or local networks are becoming more sophisticated and more robust. This is much more than the audience clicker system where the audience can push a button to answer usually a multiple choice question (A,B, C, or D). But there are systems like Twitter that can allow 'back-hallway' discussions or ability to ask questions which can be answered by the presenter in real time. Newer platforms can collate rich text entries and also collect images. Many of these allow ability to catch if the audience is out of step more efficiently by than the traditional method of waiting for someone to raise their hand. Secondly, there is also the ability for the individual learner to go down a 'rabbit hole' right away to pursue a question they may have had. For example, I interjected a clinical example of hemiballism after a lecturer was talking about subthalamic nucleus anatomy. I had not shown a video, as I just stood up and extemporaneously gave the discussion. As soon as I was done talking, a student in front of me had called up a video of hemiballism with a video demonstrating it. And these are just a few brief examples of the good that can come from online activity during a lecture.
The last point I'd like to bring up, is that this will likely not be a point of discussion soon. Our med school is considering going to a paperless system where all notes are distributed electronically. Our med school is likely a bit behind the curve on this. My point is the same devices that allow you to read PP slides, and take notes on them also play Angry Birds. There's not currently a good way to facilitate one task while blocking the other. My point is that the ability for a lecturer to demand that everyone turn off their devices. Thus, this may be analagous to a record company trying in the late Nineties to divert attention from digital devices playing their music and focusing only on
CD's. Who's bought a CD recently?
So, where do we go from here? As I look over the neuroscience course this morning, most electronic devices (except mine) are showing slides on epilepsy treatment (which is the lecture we're having today). So most people are using the technology wisely. However, with email only a click away, the temptation is strong for attention to wander? What are your thoughts?
The semi-random musings of a neurologist who first trained to be a high school teacher, and never quite left his educator days behind. Views on the blog are my own, and are not specifically endorsed by my employer.
Showing posts with label digital. Show all posts
Showing posts with label digital. Show all posts
Monday, February 6, 2012
Thursday, December 8, 2011
Paper vs Pixel - Use of On-line or traditonal books in medical education
I was at at team meeting yesterday to orient faculty to the neuroscience course I'm co-directing next year. We were going through the section where I was relaying to them our required texts for the course. One of the faculty (who happens to be a physiologist) asked which physiology text we were using for the course. On the list we have a nice neuroanatomy text, a brain atlas, a psychiatry text, a pathology text, and Harrison's. He felt the neurophysiology discussions in our clinically minded neuroantomy text were lacking, and the other faculty in the room agreed with him.
So this left me with a dilemma. Do I have switch from our current neuroanatomy text with a definite clinical foundation a more comprehensive text with neurophysiology covered more completely? Such a text was used in the past, and was felt to be too dense for the needs of medical students. Do we have them buy a text that focuses only on neurophysiology in addition to the neuroanatomy text? I think this would likely just lead to them not buying this text as we'd only need a few chapters, and I'm not sure it would be very useful for them in the future honestly. It would likely be more dense than the book we already rejected. Do we just give them the lecture notes to study from? Or do we search for/develop online references for them to use.
This last point led me to the rebuttal I had to requiring the students to buy another textbook. My impression from talking to fourth year students is that the majority of them do not buy textbooks any more. I can actually see good reason for that. First, textbooks are and always have been expensive. Textbooks are also notoriously slow to adapt to new information (new editions come out every few years, and take a year or so to develop, so are at best a year out of date, and at worst 2-3 years out of date when they are read). Compare that to most online resources which are free (or available for free through institutional subscriptions). Online resources aren't guaranteed to be updated frequently, but at least the possibility is there for them to be updated frequently. Also, with the advent of more interactive pages, there is a chance for things to be updated as new information is developed through crowd-sourcing. Hence, my idea that asking students to buy another text is foolish, as I'm not convinced that their all going to buy the first 3 books that are already on my list.
So this left me with a dilemma. Do I have switch from our current neuroanatomy text with a definite clinical foundation a more comprehensive text with neurophysiology covered more completely? Such a text was used in the past, and was felt to be too dense for the needs of medical students. Do we have them buy a text that focuses only on neurophysiology in addition to the neuroanatomy text? I think this would likely just lead to them not buying this text as we'd only need a few chapters, and I'm not sure it would be very useful for them in the future honestly. It would likely be more dense than the book we already rejected. Do we just give them the lecture notes to study from? Or do we search for/develop online references for them to use.
This last point led me to the rebuttal I had to requiring the students to buy another textbook. My impression from talking to fourth year students is that the majority of them do not buy textbooks any more. I can actually see good reason for that. First, textbooks are and always have been expensive. Textbooks are also notoriously slow to adapt to new information (new editions come out every few years, and take a year or so to develop, so are at best a year out of date, and at worst 2-3 years out of date when they are read). Compare that to most online resources which are free (or available for free through institutional subscriptions). Online resources aren't guaranteed to be updated frequently, but at least the possibility is there for them to be updated frequently. Also, with the advent of more interactive pages, there is a chance for things to be updated as new information is developed through crowd-sourcing. Hence, my idea that asking students to buy another text is foolish, as I'm not convinced that their all going to buy the first 3 books that are already on my list.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)